Wall of Fame
| Class of 2009 | |
| 1980 National Champion Team | Men's Soccer, 1980 |
| Jack VanIngen | Men's Lacrosse, 1975 |
| Renee Gates | Swimming, 1991 - 1993 |
| Class of 2007 | |
| Alex Lewis | Football and Track and Field, 2000 - 2002 |
| Bill Henggeler | Baseball, Basketball and Football, 1948 - 1950 |
| Custavious Patterson | Football, 1998 - 1999 |
| Frank Baumgardner | Ice Hockey, 2000 - 2002 |
| Jim Hall | Wrestling Coach, 1987 - 1999 |
| Paul Rose | Men's Lacrosse Coach, 1987 - 2007 |
| Class of 2006 | |
| Bob Cafarelli | Football, Basketball and Baseball, 1939 - 1940 |
| Ian Martin | Men's Soccer, 1978 - 1979 |
| James Pomilio | Football, Basketball and Baseball, 1946 |
| Stan Damon | Football, 1949 - 1950 |
| Walter Scram | Football, Basketball and Baseball, 1939 - 1940 |
| Class of 2005 | |
| Pete Vercillo | Football, 1952 - 1953 |
| Class of 2004 | |
| Dennis Nostrand | Wrestling Coach, 1983 - 1987 |
| Tom Barbur | Men's Baseball and Baseball, 1949 - 1951 |
| Class of 2000 | |
| Dom 'Carts' Caraccilo | Football and Baseball, 1952 - 1954 |
| Keith Wolling | Men's Track and Field, 1972 - 1973 |
| Michael Spohn | Wrestling, 1967 - 1969 |
| Steve Morgan | Men's Soccer and Wrestling, 1967 - 1969 |
| Tony Simone | Football, 1948 - 1950 |
| Class of 1999 | |
| Ben Collins | Men's Soccer, 1981 - 1982 |
| Kermit Nichols | Men's Cross-Country, 1938 - 1939 |
| Ralph Riese | Wrestling, 1966 - 1967 |
| William Carr | Alpine and Nordic Skiing Coach, 1970 - 1980 |
| Class of 1998 | |
| Bob Schenkenberger | Football and Baseball, 1953 - 1955 |
| Jana DeVencenzo | Women's Field Hockey, Softball and Soccer Coach, 1969 - 1997 |
| Mike McLaren | Basketball and Baseball, 1951-1953 |
| Taney Beaumont | Football, Men's Basketball and Baseball Coach, 1953 - 1962 |
| William Haflin | Football and Baseball, 1953 - 1955 |
| Class of 1997 | |
| Art Lemery | Athletic Director; Men's Soccer Coach, 1965 - 1995 |
| Conrad Mirizio | Football, Basketball and Baseball, 1949 - 1950 |
| Delos "DH" Brooks | Football Coach, 1923 - 1955 |
| Dodge Monteleone | Football, 1950 - 1951 |
| Gary Seymour | Wrestling, 1967 - 1968 |
| George Spader | Baseball & Men's Basketball Coach, 1923 - 1958 |
| Jim Weeks | Men's Basketball, 1957 - 1958 |
| John DeVencenzo | Athletic Director; Wrestling & Baseball Coach, 1962 - 1992 |
| Lisa Fuchs | Women's Soccer and Basketball, 1985 - 1986 |
| Robert Drake | Athletic Director; Football, Men's Basketball & Baseball Coach, 1948 - 1978 |
| Victor Huerta | Men's Soccer, 1973 - 1974 |